Apicoectomy vs. Root Canal Retreatment: Which One Is Right for You?

Apicoectomy vs. Root Canal Retreatment: Which One Is Right for You?

TeamUncategorized

It can be frustrating when a previously treated tooth begins hurting or showing signs of infection again. The good news is that a failed root canal doesn't automatically mean extraction. In many cases the tooth can still be saved with some additional treatment. 

Two of the main tooth-saving options that may be recommended when the first root canal fails are root canal retreatment and apicoectomy. The goal of this article is to define each procedure to help you understand which option may be best for you. 

Why a Root Canal Tooth May Need Additional Treatment

Common reasons a treated tooth doesn't heal or becomes reinfected include: 

  • Missed or complex canals. Sometimes the first root canal procedure does not remove all of the infection or pulp, often due to a complex root canal structure inside the tooth. 
  • New decay. The same tooth can develop new decay that leads to reinfection. 
  • Cracked or leaking crown or filling. The filling or crown used to seal your tooth after the first root canal can crack or become loose, allowing bacteria to seep under it. 
  • Delayed final restoration. Waiting too long to get a crown placed over a treated tooth can sometimes allow reinfection. 

Symptoms to watch for:

  • Lingering pain
  • Swelling
  • Tenderness when biting
  • Pimple-like bump on the gums

Some issues only show up only on X-rays without any noticeable symptoms, which is why follow-up exams are essential after root canal treatment. 

What Is Root Canal Retreatment?

Root canal retreatment involves reopening the tooth, removing the existing filling material, cleaning and disinfecting the canals, and then resealing the tooth. It is essentially a repeat root canal procedure that addresses problems inside the canal system, such as missed canals or contamination from a leaking restoration. The procedure can typically be completed in one or two visits, followed by a new crown or restoration. 

What Is an Apicoectomy?

An apicoectomy is a minor surgical procedure that accesses the root tip through the gums, removes the infected tissue and root tip, and places a small filling to seal the end of the root. It addresses persistent infection at the root tip, especially when the tooth already has a crown or post that would be risky to remove. Local anesthesia is used during the procedure, followed by a short recovery period, and gradual bone healing over the following months. 

Apicoectomy vs. Root Canal Retreatment: Key Differences

  • Approach: During root canal retreatment the canals are accessed through the crown vs. through the gums at the root tip for an apicoectomy. 
  • Problem location: Root canal retreatment is used when the infection is located inside the canals, whereas an apicoectomy is used when the infection is located at the end of the root. 
  • Impact on existing restorations: Retreatment usually requires removing or working through the crown, while an apicoectomy leaves it intact. 
  • Recovery and follow-up differences: An apicoectomy may require a slightly longer recovery period while the gum tissue heals, and possibly an additional follow-up appointment for suture removal. 

In certain cases both procedures may be used together if retreatment alone doesn't resolve the infection. 

How Your Endodontist Decides Which Treatment You Need

In order to determine the best treatment to save your tooth, your endodontist will perform an evaluation. This may include 3D cone beam imaging to pinpoint the source and location of the problem. They will consider factors such as the condition of the existing crown or post, the complexity of the root anatomy, previous treatment quality, and overall tooth structure. 

A specialist evaluation is especially important for complex cases, otherwise the treatment may not be effective and the tooth will need further intervention later, possibly extraction. 

Saving Your Natural Tooth Starts With the Right Diagnosis

Both root canal retreatment and apicoectomy share the same goal: preserving your natural tooth and avoiding extraction. If you start to experience new or recurring symptoms in an already treated tooth, reach out to Eagle Endodontics today to schedule an evaluation. The sooner you seek treatment, the better the chances of saving the tooth. 

Frequently Asked Questions About Apicoectomy vs. Root Canal Retreatment

Is an apicoectomy more painful than root canal retreatment?

Anesthesia is used with both procedures to numb the area being treated and keep you comfortable throughout the process. 

How long does it take to recover from each procedure?

You may need a day or two to recover from root canal retreatment, and possibly a few days more for an apicoectomy because it is a surgical procedure. 

What is the success rate of apicoectomy compared to root canal retreatment?

Both procedures have similar success rates ranging from 75% to 94%. One is not necessarily more successful than the other. The keys to success are accurate diagnosis, appropriate treatment, and timing for each case. 

Can I keep my existing crown if I need additional treatment?

In the case of apicoectomy the crown can typically remain in place. However, with root canal retreatment, the existing crown can sometimes be kept in place with a filling, but will sometimes need to be replaced. 

What happens if neither procedure is able to save my tooth?

Sometimes extraction is the only option when a tooth can’t be saved. Replacement options are available to restore function and aesthetics. 

Eagle Endodontics provides expert endodontic care in Lexington and Belmont, MA, including root canal therapy, endodontic retreatment, and apicoectomies using advanced technology like 3D cone beam imaging. If a previously treated tooth is causing discomfort, contact us today to schedule an evaluation with our experienced endodontists.